Why being the “smart one” is a trap


Enneagram Five Newsletter

Issue #017

Why being the “smart one” is a trap

Growing up, I never felt like I fit in.

I chalked it up to being wired differently. I was analytical, introspective, always thinking a few layers deeper than everyone else seemed to be. And eventually, I decided that maybe I just wasn’t meant to belong.

But that wasn’t the full story.

What I didn’t realize back then was that I had stopped trying. Not because I didn’t care, but because I cared too much.

I was terrified that trying and failing would prove my worst fear: that I wasn’t just different, I was unlovable.

So I made a quiet vow to myself:

If I couldn’t succeed socially, I would at least be smart. If I couldn’t connect, I would at least impress.

And for a while, that worked. But eventually, I started to realize that the identity I had built around being smart was quietly limiting me.

Today, we’re exploring how that strategy, while protective, can leave us feeling disconnected, stuck, and alone, and what it actually takes to feel whole again.

The trap of the smart identity

Building your identity around being the smart one might feel safe at first, but over time it becomes limiting. The more you try to protect that image, the more you avoid anything that could challenge it:

  • You don’t speak up unless you’re sure.
  • You don’t try new things unless you already know you’ll be good at them.
  • You avoid conversations that might expose the parts of you that feel underdeveloped.

And slowly, your world starts to shrink.

The truth is, when you stop risking vulnerability, you also stop building real connection.

And that’s where the loneliness starts to set in. Not because you’re incapable of connection. But because you’ve been hiding behind a version of yourself that only exists to be admired, not known.

The illusion of superiority

Eventually, that loneliness gets too loud to ignore.

And if you’re anything like me, you might respond to that pain by convincing yourself that you’re just more evolved. That you’re too deep for surface-level relationships. That you don’t need connection because you understand people better than they understand themselves.

But underneath that defensive arrogance is something much more tender:

A deep longing to be seen.

  • Not for your intellect.
  • Not for your insight.
  • Just for being human.

What you actually need

If that’s you, if you feel stuck in the role of the smart one, disconnected from the world around you, I want to offer you this:

You don’t need to be impressive to belong.

You don’t need to hide the messy, awkward, uncertain parts of yourself to be loved.

You just need to be willing to show up.

Not as the smartest person in the room. As a full, flawed, feeling human being.

Your turn

This week, try something you’re not good at.

  • Say something imperfect in a conversation.
  • Ask a question you don’t know the answer to.
  • Share a thought before it’s fully formed.

Then notice: What happens?

Does the world end? Or do you start to feel just a little more alive?

Hit reply and let me know what you try. I read every response.

Josiah Goff

Say hi 👋🏻 on Instagram, Threads, or LinkedIn

Whenever you're ready, here are some ways to go deeper:

Join the Five Community (Free) – Connect with other Fives on the same path. Join here

📘 Get your Personal Growth Playbook (Free) – In just 5 minutes, get a customized plan designed to help you grow as a Five, without feeling like you have to become a different person. Get your playbook

🎓 Master Connection as a Five – Learn practical strategies with The Art of Connection course. Get the course

🧠 Work with Me 1:1 – Personalized coaching to help you break through your biggest challenges. Book a session

110 Somerville Ave., Suite 266, Chattanooga, Tennessee 37405
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Fully Five: A Newsletter for Enneagram Fives

Go from overthinking to fully engaging, without losing your Five edge. Join 580+ Enneagram Fives getting practical, research-based strategies to help you stop retreating and start living — in your inbox for free every Saturday.

Read more from Fully Five: A Newsletter for Enneagram Fives
A man sitting on outdoor steps, smiling broadly. He has short hair and a beard, and he is wearing a blue plaid shirt. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a sunny day.

Enneagram Five Newsletter Issue #023 My favorite 3-minute brain hack for instant flow state ↓ Last month, I stumbled into a habit that surprised me: I’ve been swinging a rope in my backyard like a kid at recess. And it’s one of the best tools I’ve found for getting out of my head and into flow. Not flow like “deep creative focus after 45 minutes of fiddling with your desk setup.” I mean full-body rhythm, emotional presence, and mental clarity—within about three minutes. It’s called Rope Flow....

A man sitting on outdoor steps, smiling broadly. He has short hair and a beard, and he is wearing a blue plaid shirt. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a sunny day.

Enneagram Five Newsletter Issue #022 You’re not socially awkward—you’re emotionally cautious ↓ In high school, I used to think there was something wrong with me. I’d go to youth group and feel completely out of place. Everyone else seemed to flow so easily in conversation—making jokes, telling stories, jumping into social games—while I stood off to the side, overthinking every possible thing I could say. For years, I assumed I was just socially awkward. But looking back, I wasn’t struggling...

A man sitting on outdoor steps, smiling broadly. He has short hair and a beard, and he is wearing a blue plaid shirt. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a sunny day.

Enneagram Five Newsletter Issue #021 There’s a hidden dashboard inside you ↓ I didn’t used to think of myself as an “emotional” person. I figured if something was really wrong, I’d know because I’d think about it. Analyze it. Solve it. But looking back, most of my worst emotional spirals didn’t start with a thought. They started with a clench in my chest. A shallow breath. A tension in my jaw I didn’t notice until it was too late. By the time my brain caught up, my body had already been...