Why detachment isn’t strength


Fully Five Newsletter

Issue #034

Why detachment isn’t strength

As Fives, we tend to take pride in our ability to stay calm under pressure.

When things get chaotic, we keep our cool.
We don’t melt down.
We think clearly.

And in a world that often feels emotionally overwhelming, this self-control can feel like a superpower.

But here’s where it gets tricky: what looks like resilience is often just detachment.

Emotional detachment isn’t bad in itself. It can be useful, even protective. But when it becomes our default response, we lose access to the full depth of our emotional experience. We confuse numbness with regulation. Control with strength.

And over time, that survival strategy leaves us more fragile, not less.

Today we’re talking about how to tell the difference between healthy regulation and emotional bypassing—and how to reconnect with your emotional world in a safe, intentional way.

Numb ≠ regulated

Let’s start with some clarity.

Feeling detached can feel like you’re regulated. Your body is calm. Your thoughts are orderly. You’re not having a meltdown.

But the absence of visible emotion doesn’t mean the emotion isn’t there. It just means it’s gone underground.

Here’s how to spot the difference:

  • Detachment feels like distance: you’re observing your emotions like they belong to someone else.
  • Regulation feels like presence: you’re aware of your emotions and able to move through them with steadiness.
  • Detachment suppresses the signals your body is sending.
  • Regulation acknowledges those signals without being hijacked by them.
  • Detachment leaves you feeling empty, disconnected, or robotic.
  • Regulation leaves you feeling steady, open, and grounded.

In short: detachment protects you from feeling, while regulation equips you to handle feeling.

And while one may look like strength from the outside, only one actually builds it.

Why Fives mistake detachment for strength

This isn’t random. As Fives, we learned early on that emotions are unpredictable, messy, and hard to control.

So we built walls.

We trained ourselves to stay cool in emotional storms. We developed hyper-rationality as armor. We got good at analyzing feelings instead of experiencing them.

And the world often rewarded us for this, calling us “calm,” “composed,” or “unflappable.”

But no one saw the cost.

Because while we might avoid getting swept away by emotion, we also lose:

  • The depth of connection that comes from shared vulnerability
  • The wisdom that emotions carry when we learn how to listen
  • The resilience that comes from actually processing instead of suppressing

We didn’t mean to become emotionally numb. We just didn’t know there was another way.

How to safely reconnect with emotion

You don’t need to become emotionally explosive to grow.

The goal isn’t to swing from numb to overwhelmed. It’s to develop a kind of emotional fluency: a way of relating to your inner world that’s steady, compassionate, and responsive.

Here’s how to start:

  1. Build emotional literacy
    Start by identifying what you’re feeling, even in simple terms. Use a feeling wheel if it helps. If you don’t know, guess. Naming a feeling (even poorly) is better than ignoring it altogether.
  2. Practice body-based awareness
    Emotions show up in the body before the brain. Scan your body throughout the day and ask:
    • What’s happening in my chest, stomach, throat?
    • Is there tension, heat, constriction?
    • Can I stay with that sensation for just a few seconds without fixing it?
  3. Set time-bound containers
    If feeling emotions scares you, create limits. Give yourself two minutes to journal, five minutes to feel, ten minutes to cry. Emotional tolerance grows gradually. You don’t have to dive into the deep end.
  4. Use grounding techniques
    Stay connected to the present moment with simple practices like:
    • Noticing 3 things you see, hear, and feel
    • Putting your feet flat on the floor and taking slow breaths
    • Holding a cold object or splashing cold water on your face
  5. Debrief with curiosity, not critique
    After an emotional experience, resist the urge to analyze it to death. Instead, ask:
    • What did I notice?
    • What helped me stay present?
    • What do I want to try differently next time?

The goal isn’t to become emotional. It’s to become emotionally capable.

You don’t have to choose between being calm and being connected

True resilience is quiet strength.

It’s the ability to stay rooted even as waves move through you. You don’t have to give up your clarity or your composure. You just have to stop outsourcing safety to numbness.

Because your emotions aren’t your enemy.

They’re messengers. Allies. Bridges to a deeper, richer, more connected life.

And when you learn how to feel without being flooded, you become someone who can hold space—for yourself, for others, and for whatever life brings next.

Your turn:

Set a five-minute timer today. Ask yourself, “What am I feeling right now?” and see if you can answer without overanalyzing.

Let it be messy. Let it be uncertain. Let it be enough.

Josiah Goff

Say hi 👋🏻 on Instagram, Threads, or LinkedIn


New Episode!

What do we expect from ourselves and others as Fives?


Whenever you're ready, here are some ways to go deeper:

Join the Five Community (Free) – Connect with other Fives on the same path. Join here

📘 Get your Personal Growth Playbook (Free) – In just 5 minutes, get a customized plan designed to help you grow as a Five, without feeling like you have to become a different person. Get your playbook

🎓 Master Connection as a Five – Learn practical strategies for connecting with each Enneagram type with The Art of Connection course. Get the course

🚀 Join the Fully Five Accelerator – Break free from observer mode with a proven growth framework and the weekly support of people who truly understand how your Five brain works.
See if you're ready for FFA

110 Somerville Ave., Suite 266, Chattanooga, Tennessee 37405
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Fully Five: A Newsletter for Enneagram Fives

Go from overthinking to fully engaging, without losing your Five edge. Join 580+ Enneagram Fives getting practical, research-based strategies to help you stop retreating and start living — in your inbox for free every Saturday.

Read more from Fully Five: A Newsletter for Enneagram Fives
A man sitting on outdoor steps, smiling broadly. He has short hair and a beard, and he is wearing a blue plaid shirt. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a sunny day.

Fully Five Newsletter Issue #033 Your boundaries don’t have to be walls ↓ Quick note: this week's newsletter includes a special announcement from our friend Sam E. Greenberg, so make sure to check that out below. I used to think boundaries were just about saying no. That they were big, bold declarations to the world: “Don’t come any closer.” And in some seasons, they needed to be. I was depleted, overwhelmed, constantly saying yes when I meant no. So I did what most of us do when we first...

A man sitting on outdoor steps, smiling broadly. He has short hair and a beard, and he is wearing a blue plaid shirt. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a sunny day.

Fully Five Newsletter Issue #032 Stop trying to earn joy ↓ I used to think joy was a reward. Something that came after the work was done. After I’d figured everything out. After I’d earned the right to rest. But the more I started paying attention, the more I realized: I wasn’t just deprioritizing joy—I was avoiding it. Not because I didn’t want to feel good. Because joy felt… inefficient. When your default mode is problem-solving, joy can seem like a distraction. A luxury. Something to be...

A man sitting on outdoor steps, smiling broadly. He has short hair and a beard, and he is wearing a blue plaid shirt. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a sunny day.

Fully Five Newsletter Issue #031 You don’t need to ‘understand’ your emotions to process them ↓ I used to think I had to figure out my emotions before I could do anything with them. Like I had to trace each feeling back to its source, analyze it from every angle, and extract some kind of insight. Only then would I be allowed to feel it. But over time, I’ve learned something that’s hard to accept as a Five: understanding isn’t required. Insight is helpful, yes. But it’s not a prerequisite for...